📊 GMAT Exam Prep

To reduce carbon emissions, the city council proposes replacing all public buses with electric models. They argue this change will significantly lower the city's overall carbon footprint. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the city council's argument?

A The electricity grid that powers the city's electric vehicles relies heavily on coal-fired power plants.
B Many city residents primarily use personal vehicles, not public buses.
C Electric buses are more expensive to purchase than traditional diesel buses.
D The manufacturing process for electric buses generates significant carbon emissions.

✓ Correct Answer: Option A

The argument assumes electric buses reduce the carbon footprint. If the electricity source itself is high-emission, the overall carbon footprint might not decrease, or even increase, directly weakening the proposal's intended effect.

Related GMAT Exam Prep Questions