📊 GMAT Exam Prep

An argument states: 'Since the local library started offering free online courses, book borrowing has decreased by 20%. Clearly, the online courses are discouraging people from reading physical books, and we should discontinue them to boost traditional library usage.' Which of the following is the most significant flaw in this argument's reasoning?

A It assumes that people who take online courses no longer read physical books.
B It fails to consider alternative reasons for the decline in book borrowing.
C It does not provide data on the cost of the online courses.
D It contradicts itself by promoting online courses while criticizing them.

✓ Correct Answer: Option B

The argument assumes a direct causal relationship without exploring other potential factors (e.g., rise of e-readers, other leisure activities) that could explain the decrease in book borrowing. This is a classic causal oversimplification.

Related GMAT Exam Prep Questions