"We should not listen to Dr. Jones's dietary advice because she is overweight." This is:

Question

BrainForge Quiz · Accepted Answer

B) An ad hominem attack — the quality of advice does not depend on the adviser's personal behavior. This attacks the person rather than the argument. A doctor's personal weight does not invalidate the medical evidence behind dietary advice.

"We should not listen to Dr. Jones's dietary advice because she is overweight." This is:

✓ Correct Answer: Option B

Related LSAT Exam Prep Questions