🏫 College Advising

In a holistic review admissions process, an admissions committee is evaluating two students with similar GPAs. Student A took all honors and AP courses, earning mostly B's and some A's. Student B took standard-level courses, earning all A's. Which student's academic record is typically viewed more favorably by highly selective institutions and why?

A Student B, because a perfect GPA consistently demonstrates mastery of coursework.
B Student A, because the rigor of coursework is often prioritized over a slightly lower GPA in challenging classes.
C Student B, because universities want students who can achieve perfect grades without struggle.
D Both are viewed equally, as the GPA is the sole academic metric considered.

✓ Correct Answer: Option B

Highly selective institutions often value a challenging curriculum, even if it results in slightly lower grades, because it demonstrates a willingness to take academic risks and prepare for college-level rigor. The context of course difficulty is crucial.

Related College Advising Questions