🏥 USMLE Exam Prep

A 72-year-old patient with advanced dementia is admitted with pneumonia. The patient's durable power of attorney for healthcare is her son, who insists on full aggressive treatment, including intubation and mechanical ventilation, despite the medical team's assessment that such interventions are unlikely to improve her prognosis and would prolong suffering. Which ethical principle is primarily in conflict in this situation?

A Justice.
B Beneficence.
C Autonomy.
D Non-maleficence.

✓ Correct Answer: Option D

Non-maleficence, 'do no harm,' is in conflict when aggressive treatments are pursued that are unlikely to benefit and may increase suffering, even if requested by a surrogate decision-maker.

💡 Why is D) the correct answer?

The correct answer to the question "A 72-year-old patient with advanced dementia is admitted with pneumonia. The patient's durable power of attorney for healthcare is her son, who insists on full aggressive treatment, including intubation and mechanical ventilation, despite the medical team's assessment that such interventions are unlikely to improve her prognosis and would prolong suffering. Which ethical principle is primarily in conflict in this situation?" is Option D: Non-maleficence..

The other options — A) Justice., B) Beneficence., C) Autonomy. — are incorrect for this USMLE Exam Prep question. As explained above: Non-maleficence, 'do no harm,' is in conflict when aggressive treatments are pursued that are unlikely to benefit and may increase suffering, even if requested by a surrogate decision-maker.

📚 About This USMLE Exam Prep Practice Question

This 3-level USMLE Exam Prep question from the Step 3 – Clinical Management topic is part of BrainForge Quiz's free exam preparation library. Each question includes the correct answer and a detailed explanation to help you understand the underlying concept, not just memorize the answer.

How to use this page: Read the question above, consider all four options (A through D), then check the highlighted correct answer and explanation. For active timed practice, start a free USMLE Exam Prep practice test or use flashcards for spaced repetition review.

Related USMLE Exam Prep Questions