🏥 USMLE Exam Prep

A 45-year-old patient with end-stage renal disease, fully informed about the risks and benefits, repeatedly refuses life-sustaining hemodialysis, stating she prefers quality of life over prolongation. She is oriented and articulate. What is the most ethically appropriate response from the medical team?

A Obtain a psychiatric consultation to assess for depression and decision-making capacity.
B Respect the patient's autonomous decision and initiate palliative care discussions.
C Persuade the patient to reconsider, emphasizing the life-saving nature of dialysis.
D Seek a court order to compel treatment, citing the patient's treatable condition.

✓ Correct Answer: Option B

A patient with decision-making capacity has the right to refuse medical treatment, even if it is life-sustaining. The physician's role is to ensure the decision is informed and to respect the patient's autonomy, shifting focus to comfort care.

💡 Why is B) the correct answer?

The correct answer to the question "A 45-year-old patient with end-stage renal disease, fully informed about the risks and benefits, repeatedly refuses life-sustaining hemodialysis, stating she prefers quality of life over prolongation. She is oriented and articulate. What is the most ethically appropriate response from the medical team?" is Option B: Respect the patient's autonomous decision and initiate palliative care discussions..

The other options — A) Obtain a psychiatric consultation to assess for depression and decision-making capacity., C) Persuade the patient to reconsider, emphasizing the life-saving nature of dialysis., D) Seek a court order to compel treatment, citing the patient's treatable condition. — are incorrect for this USMLE Exam Prep question. As explained above: A patient with decision-making capacity has the right to refuse medical treatment, even if it is life-sustaining. The physician's role is to ensure the decision is informed and to respect the patient…

📚 About This USMLE Exam Prep Practice Question

This 3-level USMLE Exam Prep question from the Step 3 – Clinical Management topic is part of BrainForge Quiz's free exam preparation library. Each question includes the correct answer and a detailed explanation to help you understand the underlying concept, not just memorize the answer.

How to use this page: Read the question above, consider all four options (A through D), then check the highlighted correct answer and explanation. For active timed practice, start a free USMLE Exam Prep practice test or use flashcards for spaced repetition review.

Related USMLE Exam Prep Questions